Skip to content
PSProphet Sharing
The Ledger

Be the smartest person at the table.

Every call graded in public — the Ledger.

← Home
HitJuly 13, 2017
EssilorLuxotticaRay-BanLensCrafters
Essay2017

Why Bad Eyesight Is Going To Get (Even More) Expensive

Let me tell you why.

The call · 2017

“The Essilor-Luxottica merger creates a vertically integrated giant nobody's heard of, and your glasses stay expensive because price competition quietly dies.”

The verdictHitresolved 2021

Merger closed October 2018. EssilorLuxottica then bought GrandVision (7,000+ more stores), kept gross margins above 60%, and became the textbook example journalists reach for when they explain why a $15 frame costs $400. Price never became the differentiator.

See the full ledger →
ListenTap to listen

Let me tell you why.

This is going to require a bit of audience participation. Not too much, but just a little bit - bear with me. Have you ever heard of Ray-Ban sunglasses? What about any of the following brands that make eyewear?

  • Gucci
  • Chanel
  • Prada
  • Giorgio Armani
  • Burbery
  • DKNY
  • Dolce and Gabanna

What about the following stores that sell eyewear:

  • LensCrafters
  • Sunglass Hut
  • Sears Opticals
  • Target Opticals
  • Oakley Store

If you have less than optimal vision, chances are you own a pair of prescription glasses from one of them. If you live in a sunny area or like going to the beach, chances are you own a pair of sunglass frames from one of them. If you have perfect vision and live in a location with very little sunlight, you've at least heard of one of these brands.

Why am I telling you this? Here goes - they're all owned by the same company; ironically, by a company you've never even heard of.

You haven't heard of Luxxotica by design, not by accident. If 50% of all stores were labeled Luxxotica, most people wouldn't quite like that. If 50% of all frames were branded Luxxotica, most people wouldn't quite appreciate that.

Instead, the illusion of choice is provided, despite all the aforementioned brands being created by a single producer.

Today this Italian company is the largest eyewear company in the world, and the majority of people aren't even aware of it. Well, now that you're part of an informed eyewear minority, let's answer the grand question at hand.

Why is having bad eyesight looking to get even more expensive than it already is? And thus, I introduce you to Essilor. Of course, no one's really heard of Essilor either (same reason as stated above).

Essilor is a French based company that also holds the title of the World's largest corrective lens producer. If you wear contact lenses - I just wanted you to meet the likely creator of those marvelous little creations.

Well, guess what? These two mega powerhouses are merging. Yes, you read that correctly. The world's largest eyewear company and the world's largest producer of contact lenses are becoming one and the same.

The new optical behemoth would control every aspect of the supply chain for numerous players in the eyewear industry - an efficient vertically integrated company that can make frames, offer insurance, and sell lenses, while still galloping away with a gross profit of 64 cents for every $1 spent.

EssilorLuxxotica will be stocking its own stores primarily with self-created goods because of its cheap cost of production. What if you're a competitor who wants to sell a pair of 'Day-Bans' (I just wanted to use my initials here; please ignore the poorly fabricated name)?

Well, you can either pay a premium to have your DB frames displayed at Sunglass Hut, or you can take a hike.

The result - one enormous company that slowly but surely strangles every smaller competitor that can't produce eyewear at the same low cost that EssilorLuxottica can. According to two members of the Federal Reserve Board, [mergers] allow companies to increase profits by hiking prices. They don't improve efficiency.

Today, you may have options to choose between based on color, size, style, brand name, etc. But don't be surprised if a year down the line, price can't be one of the factors that helps you differentiate one pair of glasses from the next.

Chances are, that in that sea of supposed choice, all the water will be coming from one massive, merged, rich, glacier named EssilorLuxxotica. The craziest part of this entire narrative - the merger was announced in January of 2017. And no one even knows that Luxxotica or Essilor exist, let alone the upcoming combination of the two.

Keep Reading

Adjacent ideas from the same archive.

Essay·2018Miss

Why Amazon is Going Backwards to Move Forward

E-commerce is the future of shopping. Though some disagree, the majority of industry experts, CEOs, companies, and mom-and-pop-shop owners would tell you the same.

Amazon
Essay·2017Miss

Journalism: The Future Of Snapchat?

"Just because Yahoo has a search box doesn't mean they're Google" Evan Spiegel believes that his company has enough of a moat and a product differentiation that users won't jump over from...

SnapFacebook
Essay·2017Partial

Amazon Bought Whole Foods For This Secret Product

The first thing to note is that Jeff Bezos is a very intelligent man and that a move towards grocery has been in the works for a while now. But it's not a gamble, nor was it a binge...

AmazonWhole Foods